Why most law firm web sites stink
Ninety-seven percent of 1,000-plus corporate Web sites evaluated by Forrester Research received failing grades. Gave rise to the Wall Street Journal's Ben Worthen's column, 'Why most business web sites stink.' May have well been why most law firm web sites stink.
Harley Manning, a Forrester vice president, told Worthern the common mistakes could be broken down into four categories.
- Value. The first mistake that companies make when they're designing a Web site is copying features from competitors. Bells and whistles are worthless if they don't help a customer find what he's looking for. Manning says that too few companies take the time to sit down with customers and find out what they're using a Web site for and what information would make a site more helpful.
- Navigation. Companies often opt for cute menus instead of clear menus.
- Presentation. Web sites need to be easy to read and understand. Yet the majority of companies still feel compelled to fit as much information into as small a place as possible. Look at the text on your law firm web site. Net users scan for bolded and bulleted text. That's lacking on sites written in 'Martindaleesque' paragraph prose.
- Trust. People are concerned about online privacy and security. Calling attention to your company's privacy policy can actually help sales, Manning says. For law firms that may mean emphasis on privacy for all intake items, including email, from the website to the firm.
Rather than looking at other law firms, look at business and corporate sites for guidance. You' ll get ideas your competitors will not and you'll be looking at sites developed with far more input from Internet users.

I also think it could have something to do with the fact that it's hard for a law firm to make money from their website.
You can't easily buy their product/service online.
Re: point 4, I'm not sure sales would be greatly improved through calling attention to one's privacy policy. Have you seen some stats that back this up?
So I'd say that it's not worth going to the trouble to hire a decent usability and/or design consultant if they don't perceive that there will be some return on their investment.
We'll just get the IT guy to make one.
I agree with Dan, law firms don't see the immediate value of a website, but there are hidden returns! In our marketing department we started using more web software to provide media/web stats. That way, we have concrete data to turn around to lawyers and show them exactly what impact the website is making.
Most Canadian law firm sites are horrible for navigating and just have too much information. A lot of them don't make any attempt to catch your attention in those first few critical seconds a viewer spends on a page before they bounce.
The way I've typically sold lawyers on a good site is to let them know their site is part of their image. They've spent thousands on well-designed ads, office space, and other parts of their business and their site is an extension of that and should play the part.